![]() If the board is not satisfied with the decision, a majority of the members can decide to send the case back for re-review, convening a new panel and starting the process again on an expedited timeline. The 20-member board as a whole will then review this panel’s draft decision. After reviewing the information about the case, the panel will draft a written decision, which may include any concurring or dissenting views if the panel cannot reach consensus. At least one panel member will be from the U.S.: as every panel must have a representative from the region the decision primarily affects and, while the region technically includes Canada, the board does not currently have any Canadian members. Unlike an appellate court panel, though, the names of the panelists will not be released publicly. The board currently has 20 members, but only a five-person panel will initially consider the case. Among other things it’s very good on the process by which the board will seek to answer the question of whether Trump should be re-platformed. “They will also consider whether Facebook’s removal of the content respected international human rights standards, including on freedom of expression and other human rights.”Įvelyn Douek, an expert in online speech regulation who made a persuasive case that Facebook refer the Trump matter to the board earlier this month, walked through the implications of the board taking the case in a new post that you should very much read here. “Members will decide whether the content involved in this case violated Facebook’s Community Standards and values,” the board said in a statement. ” Facebook could have asked for an expedited review, but didn’t, meaning the board can take a full 90 days to deliberate. ![]() The board agreed to take the case more or less immediately, saying it would be referred to a panel " over the coming days. In addition to the board’s determination on whether to uphold or overturn the indefinite suspension, Facebook welcomes any observations or recommendations from the board around suspensions when the user is a political leader. We look forward to receiving the board’s decision - and we hope, given the clear justification for our actions on January 7, that it will uphold the choices we made. ![]() Trump’s access will remain suspended indefinitely. Given its significance, we think it is important for the board to review it and reach an independent judgment on whether it should be upheld. We believe our decision was necessary and right. The board itself is made up of experts and civic leaders from around the world with a wide range of backgrounds and perspectives. It is an independent body and its decisions are binding - they can’t be overruled by CEO Mark Zuckerberg or anyone else at Facebook. The board was established last year to make the final call on some of the most difficult content decisions Facebook makes. Today, Facebook is referring its decision to indefinitely suspend former US President Donald Trump’s access to his Facebook and Instagram accounts to the independent Oversight Board. But plans, as we know, can change.Īnd on Thursday they did. Earlier this week, it said it had “no plans” to bring Trump back. Facebook said Trump could not access his account while still in office, but left open the question of whether the suspension was permanent. In the wake of the insurrection at the Capitol, Facebook joined other companies in suspending Donald Trump from its platform. In the time since the board first convened, though, the mother of all cases fell into Facebook’s lap. But nearly three years after it was first conceived, the board took its first cases only last month. The board - an independent group of experts established by Facebook to adjudicate difficult questions about speech and moderation on the platform - represents a novel effort to build a kind of judicial branch for Facebook. ![]() (Pete Marovich / Getty Images)įrom the start, the biggest question hanging over the head the Oversight Board has been whether it can be seen as legitimate. Donald Trump speaks to supporters at Joint Base Andrews for his last time as President on Wednesday.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |